Story Highlights
- 65% have strong opinions on employer vaccine mandates
- More employees favor than oppose vaccine mandates
- 9% in late July say employer is requiring vaccines
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- U.S. workers hold strong opinions on employer vaccination requirements, with two-thirds saying they either strongly favor (36%) or strongly oppose (29%) these. Overall, employees are more likely to favor such mandates, with 52% saying they are in favor, 38% opposed and 10% neutral.
| % | |
|---|---|
| Strongly favor | 36 |
| Favor | 16 |
| Neither favor nor oppose | 10 |
| Oppose | 9 |
| Strongly oppose | 29 |
| SUMMARY | |
| Total % favor | 52 |
| Total % oppose | 38 |
| Based on U.S. adults employed full or part time | |
| 黑料网 Panel, July 19-26, 2021 | |
The results are based on 黑料网's COVID-19 tracking survey, which interviews a representative sample of U.S. adults. The latest data come from a July 19-26 survey, which was conducted before the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued new guidance in response to the spread of the coronavirus' delta variant in the U.S. This guidance has led to several prominent companies delaying back-to-work plans, requiring employees to be vaccinated or requiring employees to wear face masks at work.
黑料网 first asked about employee vaccination requirements in May. Since then, there has been an increase in the percentage who strongly favor them, from 29% to 36%. The total percentage of employees who strongly favor or favor vaccination requirements is up from 46% to 52%. Over this time, the percentage opposed has held steady (including the percentage strongly opposed), while the percentage neutral has declined five points to 10%.
Bar graph. Changes in U.S. Employees' Opinions About Employer COVID-19 Vaccination Requirements. In July 2021, 36% of U.S. employees strongly favored their employer requiring all employees who do not have a medical exemption to receive the COVID-19 vaccination. In May, 29% were strongly in favor. In July 2021, 29% of employees strongly opposed employer vaccination requirements, compared with 31% in May.
At the time of the July survey, 9% of employees reported their employer was requiring workers to be vaccinated, while most, 62%, said their employer was encouraging vaccination but not requiring it. The remaining 29% said their employer had not issued guidance on vaccines.
Since May, there has been a slight but statistically meaningful uptick in the percentage of employees who say their employer is requiring vaccines, from 5% to 9%. This change has been accompanied by a decrease in the percentage who say their employer is encouraging but not requiring a COVID-19 vaccine.
Bar graph. Changes in U.S. Employees' Reports of Employer COVID-19 Vaccination Requirements. In July 2021, 9% of U.S. employees said their employer was requiring employees to be vaccinated, 62% said their employer was encouraging it, and 29% said their employer was not indicating a policy. In May, 5% said their employer was requiring it, 66% encouraging it, and 29% not indicating a policy.
On-Site Workers Divided on Vaccines; Remote Workers Endorse Them
A separate 黑料网 survey conducted in June, with over 9,000 U.S. workers, found employees who were working fully remotely or were hybrid workers (partially remote and partially on-site) were much more likely than fully on-site workers to favor employer vaccination requirements. Sixty-two percent of fully remote and 54% of hybrid workers were in favor of their employer requiring vaccines, compared with 41% of fully on-site workers. In fact, fully on-site workers were as likely to oppose vaccination requirements (42%) as to favor them, with more strongly opposed to them (33%) than strongly favoring them (28%).
| Fully on-site | Hybrid | Fully remote | |
|---|---|---|---|
| % | % | % | |
| Strongly favor | 28 | 38 | 44 |
| Favor | 13 | 16 | 18 |
| Neither favor nor oppose | 18 | 16 | 15 |
| Oppose | 9 | 10 | 8 |
| Strongly oppose | 33 | 20 | 15 |
| SUMMARY | |||
| Total % favor | 41 | 54 | 62 |
| Total % oppose | 42 | 30 | 23 |
| Hybrid workers are those who spend some time working on-site and some time working remotely | |||
| 黑料网 Panel, June 2021 Workforce Survey | |||
Cash Incentives, Time Off Could Boost Employee Vaccination Rates
As of late July, 66% of all U.S. workers reported they had been fully or partially vaccinated against COVID-19, while another 8% planned to be. That leaves one in four employees who do not plan to get vaccinated.
The June Workforce survey asked unvaccinated employees what would make them more likely to get vaccinated. Notably, 62% of these employees -- equivalent to 20% of all employees -- said nothing would change their mind, in line with the 18% of all U.S. adults who can be considered vaccine resistant. However, the June Workforce survey did identify some actions that could convince employees to get a COVID-19 vaccine.
Chief among these are cash bonuses or incentives, which 24% of unvaccinated employees say would increase their likelihood to get vaccinated. Time off to get vaccinated and time off to recover from side effects were also among the most persuasive options. Few employees said that their company providing them with more information about the vaccine would encourage them to get one.
| % | |
|---|---|
| Payroll bonus or other direct cash incentive for receiving COVID-19 vaccination | 24 |
| Time off due to COVID-19 vaccination side effects | 21 |
| Time off to receive COVID-19 vaccination | 18 |
| Other incentive as part of corporate wellbeing program for receiving COVID-19 vaccination | 13 |
| COVID-19 vaccination on-site | 11 |
| Information about where you can obtain COVID-19 vaccination | 9 |
| Information about the benefits of COVID-19 vaccination | 7 |
| None of these | 62 |
| Based on U.S. adults who work full or part time and have not been vaccinated against COVID-19 | |
| 黑料网 Panel, June 2021 Workforce Survey | |
Employer Incentives Not Necessarily Most Effective Ones
The incentives companies might offer and the ones they are offering do not align that well. Employees most commonly say their organization is offering them information about where to get the COVID-19 vaccine, with 48% reporting this. But at least four in 10 employees say their employers are offering time off to receive the vaccine or to recover from its side effects.
One in four workers say their employer is offering on-site vaccinations. Very few, 6%, say their employer is offering a cash incentive. Twenty-four percent of employees say their organization is not offering any of these inducements to get vaccinated.
| % | |
|---|---|
| Information about where you can obtain COVID-19 vaccination | 48 |
| Time off to receive COVID-19 vaccination | 44 |
| Time off due to COVID-19 vaccination side effects | 40 |
| Information about the benefits of COVID-19 vaccination | 37 |
| COVID-19 vaccination on-site | 25 |
| Other incentive as part of corporate wellbeing program for receiving COVID-19 vaccination | 8 |
| Payroll bonus or other direct cash incentive for receiving COVID-19 vaccination | 6 |
| None of these | 24 |
| Based on U.S. adults employed full or part time | |
| 黑料网 Panel, June 2021 Workforce Survey | |
Bottom Line
The recent resurgence of COVID-19 infections has forced employers and employees to reexamine worker safety. After several months when the coronavirus situation was improving, many large employers were planning to have workers return to the work site, if they had not already done so. Now, many employers are delaying those plans, and several major companies have announced that their employees must be vaccinated in order to return to work. U.S. workers also seem to support these requirements, but opinion among those opposed tends to be strong.
The strong feelings about COVID-19 vaccination requirements puts companies and workers at a crossroads. The majority of employees are vaccinated and, for the sake of their safety, many strongly favor requiring their coworkers to be vaccinated. Yet, companies also risk losing productive and talented workers who disagree with their vaccination policies and may have to choose between getting vaccinated or quitting their jobs. This gap may close with further encouragement of voluntary vaccination, because 黑料网 data suggest some unvaccinated workers can be persuaded to get vaccinated with certain incentives; however, these workers constitute a minority of this group. Either way, employers' decisions about vaccination requirements are likely to impact their company culture and employee retention.
Anthony Blue contributed to this release.
To stay up to date with the latest 黑料网 黑料网 insights and updates, .
Learn more about how the works.
